Saturday, April 9, 2016

Stereo > Mono Line Level Mixer - ***Revised 4/12/21***

Mixing line level stereophonic signals into full dimensional monophonic ;)


Here's a DIY project for mono aficionados that's so basic, I should have uploaded it many years ago. But other things got in the way.


Just like an MC step-up, these are entirely passive devices. 


The simplest way to convert stereo to mono is to connect left and right channels via a Y connector. But there's a more elegant way than just shorting two channels.


Resistors can blend two signals into one better by...


...using Allen-Bradley carbon composition for warmer sound ;)

Line Output Transformers


This single UTC A-20 transformer was in a box lot of tubes and parts I picked up at a radio show. It's a high quality transformer designed for mic, mixer or line matching applications. Instead of trying to find a mate for MC step-up duty, I repurposed it for a greater calling in my mono rig.

With a claimed bandwidth of 10-50,000 hz and dual windings in the primary and secondary, it is perfect for mixing line level stereo signals into mono!

Left and right channels from a stereo source are fed into each primary winding. The summed mono output is taken from the series-connected secondary winding, which goes into the line level input of a mono preamp.


April 12, 2021 update!


The Covid 19 lockdown was a good opportunity to reassess past projects.


I realized that my original practice of connecting the left and right stereo channels to the split primaries of a single UTC A20 line transformer was sonically inferior to the 2 x Tamura line transformers with their secondaries connected in series as shown above. 


The classic UTC A20 and A21 are still very fine contenders but two are needed instead of one. Use the specs above as a guide for hunting transformers under the radar. 

If you prefer modern transformers, I highly recommend contacting dave slagle of Intact Audio. He winds fine sounding transformers to spec using high quality materials.

He generously provided the following technical explanation as to why my original recommendation was flawed.
  • if the L & R outputs share the same core they are effectively in parallel even if the secondaries are connected in series
  • if the L & R are on discrete cores and the secondaries are in parallel the circuit can be drawn as one channel driving the other through two transformers
  • if the L & R are on discrete cores and the secondaries in series then the load is also part of the series circuit so a high impedance is reflected back


Subjectively, using a single transformer I heard truncated frequency extremes, compressed dynamics and less detail. With two transformers the sound was cleaner and more articulate with more extension at frequency extremes. Dynamic nuances at micro and macro levels improved significantly. There's also a greater sense of space and ambience!

12 comments:

  1. Hi,
    If I want to convert to the monaural two-channel recording , I can use this way?
    Thx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes this blog is about mixing stereo signals into mono.

      Delete
  2. So If I wanted 2 channel Mono from the stereo output of my preamp I just attach 2 rca jacks instead of 1? Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If you want two channel mono output from a stereo source, you have to install 2 x RCA jacks at the output of the mixing transformer.

      JE

      Delete
  3. After reading this post, and several other mono related posts, and having a mint Altec 1505/288c fall into my lap, I had to build my own mono rig:

    https://photos.app.goo.gl/ZpKDsVZ1DXjDw25KA

    I also mounted an Alnico JBL 2402, and put together a quick and dirty crossover:

    https://photos.app.goo.gl/B7sEjxwG5o4f2Bkb9

    UTC A-20 mixing stereo to mono:

    https://photos.app.goo.gl/w1Ndlk2TbKnlplCO2

    LF is 4x Alpha 15a, wired series parallel, low passed @~500hz.

    Amplification is a Crown D75, for now. I'm stashing parts for a 2A3 SE amp to power the 1505 and 2402 at some point.

    I have to say, I never thought I would like a mono system so much. I am really blown away by it.

    Thank you for the inspiration!!

    Cheers,
    Gable

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cool mono hifi rig brewing there. Thanks for the kind words. Happy listening and tinkering!

      JE

      Delete
  4. Wouldn't the input impedance of those separate primary windings be quite low?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, but I haven't heard much roll off from low Z sources.

      JE

      Delete
  5. Hi Joseph, I've found a few hen's teeth laying around but these Tamura 423 226 are impossible! heh. Any chance we could get a couple of readily available transformers that would do the trick? all best, Cuong

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The point of my update was about using a pair of 1:1 transformers instead of a single unit. So a pair of UTC A20s will work. There are so many 1:1 transformers available used or brand new, just get a pair.

      Delete
  6. hallo!! if I want to use xlr jack instead of rca jack how is it done??

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No experience with XLRs, but I'm sure Google is your friend.

      Delete